15 Best Criminal Minds Episodes Ranked by Viewers

According to viewer rankings, the top 15 episodes of Criminal Minds include high-tension, impactful installments like 'Masterpiece' (S4E8), noted for its intricate portrayal of the UnSub, and '100' (S5E9), lauded for its emotional depth and exploration of the Reaper. 'The Fisher King' (S2E1) and 'Revelations' (S2E15) pull viewers in with gripping narratives, while the milestone episode '300' (S14E1) proudly illustrates the show's enduring appeal. Other remarkable episodes include 'Damaged' (S3E14), 'Penelope' (S3E9), 'Mayhem' (S4E1), 'Minimal Loss' (S4E3), 'The Replicator', 'Lauren' (S6E18), 'The Tall Man' (S14E5), 'Entropy' (S11E11), 'Oedipus Wrecks' (S16E5), and 'Mr. Scratch' (S10E21).

These episodes are celebrated for their intricate storylines, character development, and psychological depths. If you are interested in more detailed insights about these standout episodes, be sure to maintain your exploration further.

Key Takeaways

• 'Masterpiece' (S4E8) and '100' (S5E9) are highly rated for their intense storylines and emotional depth.
• 'The Fisher King' (S2E1) and 'Revelations' (S2E15) captivate viewers with their gripping narratives and psychological impacts.
• The episode '300' (S14E1) is a fan-favorite due to its significant achievement for the show and impactful storytelling.
• 'Damaged' (S3E14) and 'Penelope' (S3E9) highlight the character depth of Rossi and Garcia, respectively.
• Other top episodes include 'Mayhem' (S4E1), 'Minimal Loss' (S4E3), 'The Replicator', 'Lauren' (S6E18), 'The Tall Man' (S14E5), 'Entropy' (S11E11), 'Oedipus Wrecks' (S16E5), and 'Mr. Scratch' (S10E21).

"Masterpiece" (S4E8)

One of the most acclaimed episodes of Criminal Minds is 'Masterpiece' (S4E8), which captivates viewers with its intense storyline, remarkable character performances, and an intricately conceived UnSub that showcases the BAU's adept profiling skills.

The driving force behind the suspenseful atmosphere is the disturbing UnSub, creating twisted crime scenes that challenge and engage the BAU team. The psychological depth of the characters, portrayed convincingly by the cast, adds another layer of complexity, making 'Masterpiece' a standout episode.

The BAU's profiling skills are also on full display as they unravel the UnSub's motives, exemplifying their strategic approach in solving crimes. The unexpected twists hold the viewers' interest, confirming 'Masterpiece' as an episode that truly embodies the essence of Criminal Minds.

"100" (S5E9)

Marking a celebratory milestone in the series, '100' (S5E9) focuses on the menacing Reaper, thereby exploring personal risks and high-stakes storytelling that have been highly praised by the audience for their emotional depth and impact.

Highlighting the 100th episode, the story delves into the BAU team's most formidable adversary, the Reaper, which escalates the stakes immensely, creating an atmosphere of tension and danger.

The episode's high-stakes storytelling is intensified by deeply personal risks, which enriches the viewers' emotional engagement.

Season 5's '100' achieves an intricate balance between suspense, character development, and narrative progression, proving why it deserves its high viewer ranking.

"The Fisher King" (S2E1)

Diving into the gripping narrative of 'The Fisher King' (S2E1), the episode presents an intense two-part case that immediately captivates viewers with its combination of thrilling plotline and tragic backstory of the villain, Randall Garner. Season 2 sets a higher bar with this fan-favorite narrative.

The episodes are not just about exploring a case; they probe deep into the psychological impact of the unsub's actions on the Behavioral Analysis Unit team. The societal challenges reflected through Garner's character add a layer of depth, making the viewer experience more intense.

The well-knit plotline keeps fans engaged and invested in the storyline. 'The Fisher King' stands out in the roster of Criminal Minds episodes for its intricate storytelling and emotional depth.

"Revelations" (S2E15)

Shifting focus to 'Revelations' (S2E15), the episode meticulously examines the psychological trauma and team dynamics following Tobias Hankel's abduction of Reid. This narrative is significant due to:

1. Its exploration of Reid's vulnerability juxtaposed with his inner strength.
2. The emotional depth and impactful storytelling that strike a chord with viewers.
3. The BAU team's resilience and unyielding solidarity in crisis.

'Revelations' presents an intense cat-and-mouse game between Reid and Hankel, adding a thrilling element to the storyline. The episode successfully delves into the psyche of a victim, the perpetrator, and the team battling to resolve the crisis.

Therefore, 'Revelations' stands out as a compelling Criminal Minds episode, reflecting the series' strengths in character development and emotional resonance.

"300" (S14E1)

Celebrating a landmark in the series, '300' (S14E1) not only represents a significant achievement for Criminal Minds but also underscores the enduring appeal and success of the BAU team. This milestone episode is a proof of the series' lasting popularity and the BAU team's compelling dynamics, which have captivated viewers over the course of 300 episodes.

Recognized as a fan-favorite, '300' stands out for its impactful storytelling, offering a riveting narrative that marks a major event in the show's history. The exceptional execution of this episode, filled with memorable moments, further highlights the series' achievement.

This 300th episode showcases the quality of Criminal Minds, solidifying its place in the annals of remarkable television productions.

"Damaged" (S3E14)

In the compelling 'Damaged' (S3E14), Criminal Minds foregrounds the tenacious commitment of Rossi to solving a cold case involving a serial killer, thereby adding significant depth to his character and driving an intense narrative that resonates with viewers. This episode is a powerful validation of Rossi's unwavering dedication and his relentless pursuit of justice, illustrated by his determination to bring closure to the cold case.

1. 'Damaged' underscores Rossi's character development, showcasing his personal connection to the case which fuels his commitment.
2. This episode shines a spotlight on Rossi's investigative skills, demonstrating his meticulous approach to unearthing the truth.
3. Rossi's quest for justice in this episode encapsulates his character's ethos, cementing 'Damaged' as a viewer favorite.

"Penelope" (S3E9)

Delving into the gripping narrative of 'Penelope' (S3E9), the episode brings tech expert Garcia's character into the spotlight, as she becomes the target of a serial killer, thereby creating a riveting storyline that underscores her resilience and strength. It takes us on an emotional journey as Garcia battles her vulnerability while demonstrating her courage in the face of personal threat.

The episode successfully highlights the depth of Garcia's character and her critical role within the BAU team. The relationships she shares with team members are explored, providing a sense of belonging for the audience. 'Penelope' is not just a showcase of Garcia's resilience, but also a reflection of the enduring camaraderie and mutual support within the BAU team when one of their own is in danger.

"Mayhem" (S4E1)

Kicking off the fourth season of 'Criminal Minds,' 'Mayhem' (S4E1) unfolds as an electrifying thriller set against the backdrop of New York City, encapsulating a tense narrative that tests the relationship between team members Hotch and Derek, and ensnares viewers with its suspenseful plotline.

Three key elements elevate this episode:

1. Season premiere: The episode successfully sets the stage for the rest of the season, establishing a high-stakes atmosphere.
2. Tension between team members: The intense dynamic between Hotch and Derek adds layers to the suspenseful narrative.
3. New York City: The city's landscape contributes to the intense plotline, making it an integral part of the narrative.

'Mayhem' expertly blends tension, thrill, and character relationships, making it a viewer favorite.

"Minimal Loss" (S4E3)

Breaking away from its typical serial killer narratives, 'Minimal Loss' (S4E3) plunges the Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU) into a high-stakes stand-off at a cult compound, testing their negotiation skills in a gripping and psychologically intense scenario.

This unique twist in the series' narrative introduces viewers to a new dimension of danger as the BAU faces Benjamin Cyrus, a menacing cult leader. The psychological dynamics at play within the cult and the tense stand-off scenario test the team's mettle in ways not seen in conventional crime-solving episodes.

The episode brilliantly showcases the BAU's strategic problem-solving abilities in high-risk situations, providing a riveting viewing experience that creates a sense of belonging among the audience, as they navigate this high-stakes situation alongside the team.

"The Replicator" (S8E24)

In 'The Replicator' (S8E24), a thrilling and suspenseful narrative unfolds as the BAU team is targeted by a chilling villain who orchestrates high-stakes copycat crimes, introducing a unique dynamic to the series. John Curtis, known as The Replicator, engages in a psychological warfare with the team, consistently staying one step ahead, and leaving audiences on edge.

The episode's appeal lies in:

1. The personal vendetta of Curtis against the BAU, intensifying the stakes.
2. The cat-and-mouse chase between the BAU and The Replicator, delivering suspenseful twists.
3. The psychological warfare, pulling the viewer deeper into the narrative.

In essence, 'The Replicator' strikes a chord with viewers who crave belonging, offering a riveting mix of tension, thrill, and emotional depth.

"Lauren" (S6E18)

Delving into the complex dynamics of loyalty, trust, and personal history, 'Lauren' (S6E18) provides a profound exploration of Emily Prentiss's secretive past and her dangerous entanglement with a felon from her earlier undercover operations.

The episode heightens the emotional depth of the series, bringing a new layer of intrigue and suspense. The criminal connection is not only a threat to Emily but also tests the BAU team's resilience and unity. The team's loyalty to Emily is challenged, revealing the underlying trust that binds them.

The episode offers viewers a closer look at Emily's undercover past, providing a context for her character that resonates with the audience's desire for belonging, all while maintaining an intense pace that keeps viewers riveted.

"The Tall Man" (S14E5)

Exploring the intricate layers of JJ's character, 'The Tall Man' (S14E5) illuminates her emotional journey and personal history, providing a profound understanding of her motivations and resilience. This episode uniquely contributes to the Criminal Minds series by:

1. Diving into JJ's backstory, revealing her past trauma and the pivotal moment that shaped her character.
2. Showcasing a remarkable performance by AJ Cook, capturing the emotional depth of JJ's development.
3. Emphasizing JJ's resilience as she confronts her past while balancing BAU duties.

'The Tall Man' brilliantly portrays JJ's complex character, resonating with viewers who seek a sense of belonging. It not only deepens our understanding of her journey but also our admiration for her strength.

"Entropy" (S11E11)

Moving from the emotional depth of 'The Tall Man', our attention turns to 'Entropy' (S11E11), an episode that stands out for its intense psychological drama and complex character interplay, particularly featuring the cunning villain, Cat Adams.

This season 11 offering escalates the stakes, as Adams employs psychological manipulation to target the Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU) team, introducing a heightened thrilling element.

The intricate narrative style, characterized by the intense cat-and-mouse game between Adams and the BAU team, resonates deeply with viewers. The episode's high stakes, coupled with the compelling performances, cement 'Entropy' as a standout in the Criminal Minds catalogue.

This intricate exploration of character dynamics and psychological intensity truly exemplifies the series' capacity for engaging storytelling.

"Oedipus Wrecks" (S16E5)

Shifting our attention to the fifth episode of season 16, 'Oedipus Wrecks' presents a captivating storyline that examines the life of a senator's son turned serial killer, providing viewers with a compelling exploration of the intricate interplay between political and personal dynamics.

This episode is celebrated for its:

1. Intriguing storyline – The plot delves into the shadowy side of politics and the devastating effects of personal trauma.
2. Psychological motivations – The narrative analyzes the factors propelling the senator's son towards a life of crime, illuminating his troubled psyche.
3. Engrossing performances – The cast delivers convincing portrayals, bringing to the forefront the tensions and struggles inherent in the storyline.

In essence, 'Oedipus Wrecks' stands out for its examination of political dynamics and the unsettling journey of a senator's son, providing a narrative rich in psychological insights and characterized by captivating performances.

"Mr. Scratch" (S10E21)

Shifting gears from the political intrigues and personal traumas of 'Oedipus Wrecks', we now examine the chilling episode 'Mr. Scratch' (S10E21), a masterclass in psychological manipulation and tense storytelling. This fan-favorite episode introduces the sinister recurring villain Mr. Scratch, a figure skilled in psychological manipulation, who targets the BAU team in a high-stakes mind game. The BAU team's vulnerability is laid bare as they grapple with this cunning adversary.

Episode Key Elements	Details	Impact
Recurring Villain	Mr. Scratch	Heightens suspense
Psychological Manipulation	Used against the BAU team	Intensifies the storyline
High-Stakes Scenario	BAU team's vulnerability exposed	Cultivates viewer engagement

The psychological tension and gripping narrative make 'Mr. Scratch' a standout episode, earning its place among the best Criminal Minds episodes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the Highest Rated Episode of Criminal Minds?

The highest rated Criminal Minds episode is 'Entropy'. Its narrative structure, emotional depth, character development, and plot twists deeply impacted viewers. This episode's unique blend of psychological manipulation and high stakes garnered exceptional viewer ratings.

What Is the Scariest Episode of Criminal Minds?

The 'Mosley Lane' episode of Criminal Minds, known for its chilling performances and disturbing storyline involving child abduction, stands out as a fear-inducing, nightmare episode due to its creepy unsub and scary plot.

Who Is the Most Liked Criminal Minds Character?

Through character development analysis and favorite character polls, it's apparent that Spencer Reid, portrayed by Matthew Gray Gubler, is the most liked character in Criminal Minds, owing to his emotional depth and compelling backstory.

Who Is the Best Unsub in Criminal Minds?

When it comes to the best Unsub in Criminal Minds, the jury's out. Unsub portrayal analysis, character development, motivation study, and profiling techniques all factor in. However, impact on team often tips the scale towards Mr. Scratch.

Conclusion

To summarize, this list, compiled based on viewer ratings, showcases the diversity and ingenuity of Criminal Minds' narrative. Each episode, from 'Masterpiece' to 'Mr. Scratch', provides unique insights into criminal psychology, keeping audiences captivated.

Despite potential objections regarding the inclusion of later seasons, these episodes exhibit the series' ability to maintain suspense and intrigue, evoking emotional responses from viewers and affirming the show's enduring appeal.